Below are the lowest available, live, real-time Medicare supplement insurance quotes in Butler County, Pennsylvania.

To find the exact rates for you or your family call (844) My-Gurus or enter your zip code to the right.

Rates are updated at least weekly, these Medigap premiums were last updated on 09/30/2025

844-694-8787	Plan A Plan Details Price	Plan B Plan Details Price	Plan F Plan Details Price	Plan G Plan Details Price	Plan K Plan Details Price	Plan L Plan Details Price
Best Rate	$85.20	$131.64	$179.70	$143.80	$54.01	$91.68
2nd Best	$138.28	$141.62	$182.81	$154.76
3rd Best	$144.55	$151.28	$200.40	$154.90
4th Best	$149.84	$153.53	$230.27	$183.43
5th Best	$154.13	$154.43	$234.07	$192.88

Show All Medigap Rates in Butler County, Pennsylvania